Is 458 E 51st St rent stabilized?
458 E 51st St is a registered NYC rent-stabilized building in East Flatbush-Rugby, Brooklyn (11203). It has about 53 apartments, built in 1940.
Also written as 458 East 51st Street — or 458 E 51st St, Brooklyn, NY 11203.
How this building compares
With about 53 apartments it is larger than 94% of the 208 rent-stabilized buildings this site tracks in East Flatbush-Rugby. Its 1940 construction date sits close to the 1930 median for stabilized buildings tracked in the neighborhood. HPD lists 69 open violations here, about 1.3 per apartment — below the 1.8 per apartment median for tracked buildings in the neighborhood. Of the 927 violations on record at the address, 269 are class C — HPD's immediately hazardous grade. Tenants have filed 870 HPD complaints at the address, 48 of them in the last twelve months.
Building details
| Borough | Brooklyn |
| Neighborhood | East Flatbush-Rugby |
| ZIP | 11203 |
| Year built | 1940 |
| Apartments | 53 |
| Rent-stabilized | Yes — DHCR registered |
| Stabilization code | MULTIPLE DWELLING A |
| BBL | 3046980037 |
Owner & management
| Owner | 458 East 51st Street Partners LLC 261 Lenox Road OFFICE · Brooklyn, NY 11226 |
| Managing agent | Jay Silver |
Building conditions
| HPD violations | 69 open / 927 total · 80 in last 12 mo |
| HPD complaints | 1 open / 870 total |
| HPD registration last filed | November 21, 2025 |
Full building report — $9
Other rent-stabilized buildings in East Flatbush-Rugby
See all in East Flatbush-Rugby →