Is 458 E 51st St rent stabilized?
458 E 51st St is a registered NYC rent-stabilized building in East Flatbush-Rugby, Brooklyn (11203). It has about 53 apartments, built in 1940.
Also written as 458 East 51st Street — or 458 E 51st St, Brooklyn, NY 11203.
How this building compares
With about 53 apartments it is larger than 94% of the 208 rent-stabilized buildings this site tracks in East Flatbush-Rugby. Its 1940 construction date sits close to the 1930 median for stabilized buildings tracked in the neighborhood. HPD lists 32 open violations here, about 0.6 per apartment — below the 1.9 per apartment median for tracked buildings in the neighborhood. Of the 933 violations on record at the address, 269 are class C — HPD's immediately hazardous grade, and 14 of them are still open. HPD issued 81 new violations at the address in the last twelve months.
Building details
| Borough | Brooklyn |
| Neighborhood | East Flatbush-Rugby |
| ZIP | 11203 |
| Year built | 1940 |
| Apartments | 53 |
| Rent-stabilized | Yes — DHCR registered |
| Stabilization code | MULTIPLE DWELLING A |
| BBL | 3046980037 |
Owner & management
| Owner | 458 East 51st Street Partners LLC 261 Lenox Road OFFICE · Brooklyn, NY 11226 |
| Managing agent | Jay Silver |
Building conditions
| HPD violations | 32 open / 933 total · 81 in last 12 mo |
| HPD complaints | 3 open / 873 total |
| HPD registration last filed | November 21, 2025 |
Full building report — $9
Frequently asked questions
Is 458 E 51st St rent stabilized?
458 E 51st St in East Flatbush-Rugby, Brooklyn is registered as rent stabilized in the New York State DHCR 2024 rent-stabilized building files, where its stabilization code is MULTIPLE DWELLING A. Registration is recorded for the building, not for each apartment in it, so an individual unit here can still have been deregulated — ask the landlord or DHCR for that apartment's rent history before relying on it.
How many apartments are at 458 E 51st St?
458 E 51st St (BBL 3046980037) has about 53 residential apartments and was built in 1940, from NYC PLUTO. PLUTO counts the building's units; it does not say how many of them are rent stabilized.
Other rent-stabilized buildings in East Flatbush-Rugby
See all in East Flatbush-Rugby →